banner

REGULAR BOARD MEETING
Sylvan Union SD
October 29, 2019 7:00PM
SYLVAN UNION SCHOOL DISTRICT OFFICE BOARD ROOM 605 SYLVAN AVENUE, MODESTO, CA 95350

1. CALL TO ORDER (SUPERINTENDENT'S OFFICE)
Time Certain:
6:00 PM
2. ADJOURN TO CLOSED SESSION
2.a. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - EXISTING LITIGATIONConfidential agenda item.
Time Certain:
6:00 PM
Quick Summary / Abstract:

(Government Code 54956.95) Number of Cases: One (1)

2.b. CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORConfidential agenda item.
Time Certain:
6:10 PM
Quick Summary / Abstract:

(Education Code 54957.6) District Negotiator: Debra M. Hendricks and Didi Peterson
Employee Organizations: All Groups (Sylvan Educators Association, California School Employees Association, Chapter 73, and Unrepresented)



2.c. PUBLIC EMPLOYEE EMPLOYMENTConfidential agenda item.
Time Certain:
6:35 PM
Quick Summary / Abstract:
(Education Code 54957)

Title: Administrative Assignments




3. RECONVENE TO OPEN SESSION (BOARDROOM)
Time Certain:
7:00 PM
4. BOARD PRESIDENT ANNOUNCEMENT
4.a. IN ACCORDANCE WITH BOARD POLICY, THIS ANNOUNCEMENT IS TO ADVISE ALL ATTENDEES THAT TONIGHT'S BOARD MEETING IS BEING RECORDED.
4.b. PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS THE BOARD ON ANY AGENDA OR NON-AGENDIZED ITEM MUST FILL OUT A SPEAKER CARD.
5. REPORT OUT OF CLOSED SESSION
6. ADOPTION OF AGENDA
7. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
7.a. ORCHARD ELEMENTARY SCHOOL STUDENT TO LEAD THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
8. RECOGNITION PRESENTATION
Time Certain:
7:05 PM
8.a. ORCHARD ELEMENTARY SCHOOL TO BE RECOGNIZED
9. COMMUNICATIONS
9.a. WRITTEN COMMUNICATION
Rationale:

The Board of Trustees received a letter from Stanislaus County Office of Education notifying the district our 2019-20 LCAP and adopted budget was approved.


 
Attachments:
SCOE LCAP AND BUDGET ADOPTION APPROVED
9.b. PUBLIC HEARING: CSEA INITIAL PROPOSAL FOR 2019-2020 CONTRACT NEGOTIATIONS
Rationale:

The District and California School Employees Association, Chapter 73 (CSEA) are preparing to reopen bargaining for the 2019-2020 year. The District presented its “Sunshine Proposal” for 2019-2020 negotiations with CSEA as public information on August 27, 2019.

CSEA, Chapter 73 has now provided its “Sunshine Proposal” for 2019-2020 negotiations.  At this meeting on October 29, 2019, the Board of Trustees will hold a public hearing on this initial proposal for bargaining between the District and CSEA, Chapter 73 for 2019-2020.

 
Quick Summary / Abstract:

The Sylvan Union School District and the California School Employees Association, Chapter 73 are preparing to open bargaining for 2019-2020.  CSEA, Chapter 73 is presenting its “Sunshine Proposal” for 2019-2020 negotiations.

Attachments:
CSEA SUNSHINE PROPOSAL 2019-2020
9.c. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
10. INFORMATION AND DISCUSSION
10.a. SUPERINTENDENT'S UPDATE: CSBA AEC PRESENTATION
Time Certain:
7:40 PM
Speaker:
Debra M. Hendricks, Superintendent
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Debra M. Hendricks, Superintendent

The Superintendent will share information about the district's California School Boards Association Annual Educators Conference presentation session at the AEC in December 2019.

 
10.b. PRESENTATION: SYLVAN EDUCATIONAL FOUNDATION MINI-GRANT RECIPIENTS
Time Certain:
7:45 PM
Speaker:
Debra M. Hendricks, Superintendent and David Collins, Board President
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Debra M. Hendricks and David Collins, Board President 

The mission of the Sylvan Educational Foundation (SEF) is to provide educational enhancement, professional enrichment, and community involvement in support of our children.  SEF will be introducing the 2019-2020 Mini-Grant recipients.  SEF was able to fund thirty-one (31) projects totaling $ 25,677.02 for the 2019-2020 school year.  

The annual Gourmet Breakfast and Kids Fun Run will be held on Saturday, February 22, 2020, at Somerset Middle School.  Due to Ustach's Modernization Project, the breakfast will be held at Somerset Middle School.  The annual breakfast is from 8:00-11:00 AM.




 
10.c. FALL 2019 CA SCHOOL DASHBOARD LOCAL INDICATORS
Time Certain:
7:50 PM
Speaker:
Marti Reed, Director of Categorical Programs
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Marti Reed, Director of Categorical Programs 

The State Board of Education (SBE) approved standards for the CA School Dashboard local indicators as part of the state accountability system that support local educational agencies (LEAs) in measuring and reporting their progress within the appropriate priority area. For each local indicator, the approved standard includes:

  • Annually measure progress on the local performance indicator based on locally available data.

  • Report results at a regularly scheduled public meeting of the local governing board.

  • Report results to the public through the Dashboard.

The collection and reflection on locally available information relevant to progress on local priority areas will support LEAs in local planning and improvement efforts. For the Fall 2019 Dashboard release, an LEA must complete the local indicators by November 1, 2019, in order to receive a Met rating. If the local educational agency does not complete the self-reflection tool for a local indicator by the deadline, the Dashboard will show as Not Met by default.

 
Attachments:
Fall 2019 CA School Dashboard Local Indicators Presentation
10.d. WOODROW 2019-2020 WILLIAMS MONITORING
Time Certain:
8:05 PM
Speaker:
Marti Reed, Director of Categorical Programs
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Marti Reed, Director of Categorical Programs 

The California Department of Education and the California County Superintendents Educational Services Association have been working with the organization that originated the cause for action to review the proposal incorporating the new assessment for evaluation as to implementation for Williams Act monitoring.  This new assessment for evaluation was not determined prior to the start of the 2019-2020 school year.  These groups are looking at using the California School Dashboard to replace the Academic Performance Indicator reports that were part of the retired No Child Left Behind.  Previously identified Williams Monitoring schools are still required to follow California Education Code Section 1240(c)(2)(F) and (J) specific that county superintendents must monitor docile 1-3 schools for: a) Sufficiency of instructional materials; b)  Facilities deficiencies; c) Accuracy of data reported on the School Accountability Report Card (SARC) related to sufficiency of materials and facilities deficiencies; and d) Teacher misassignments and teacher vacancies.

Attached are the Woodrow Reports for instructional materials and facilities.  There were no insufficiencies of instructional materials found. The facilities report produced a rating of exemplary.


 
Attachments:
2019-2020 Williams Monitoring Facilities Inspection Report Woodrow Elementary School
2019-2020 Woodrow Monitoring Instructional Materials Report
10.e. 2019-2020 FALL GOVERNANCE AND SUPERINTENDENT GOALS UPDATE
Time Certain:
8:10 PM
Speaker:
Debra M. Hendricks, Superintendent
Quick Summary / Abstract:

SPEAKER: Debra M. Hendricks, Superintendent 

The Board of Trustees to receive the 2019-2020 Governance and Superintendent Goals Fall update.






Attachments:
GOVERNANCE GOALS 2019-2020 - FALL UPDATE
10.f. ED SERVICES UPDATE: STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT REPORT
Time Certain:
8:15 PM
Speaker:
Laura Granger, Assistant Superintendent of Ed Services
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Laura Granger, Assistant Superintendent of Ed Services 

Staff to update the Board of Trustees on student achievement as measured by Spring 2019 SBAC results in English Language Arts/Literacy and Mathematics in grades three through eight. 




 
Attachments:
2019 SBAC Results
10.g. PROJECT AND INFRASTRUCTURE UPDATE FROM DATAPATH
Time Certain:
8:25 PM
Speaker:
Laura Granger, Assistant Superintendent of Ed Services
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Laura Granger, Assistant Superintendent of Ed Services

DataPath, Sylvan's contracted service provider for IT management, will update the Board of Trustees on progress towards ensuring network security. In addition, DataPath staff will provide an update on server virtualization, backups, phone systems, and secure wireless in efforts to improve our core infrastructure. 



 
10.h. LEASING STUDENT AND STAFF TECHNOLOGY DEVICES
Time Certain:
8:40 PM
Speaker:
Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services 

We have been providing information to the Board of Trustees in regards to the technology needs of the district.  Our current technology needs of most urgency include various devices for students and staff.  For our students, we need to replace chromebooks at our middle and elementary schools.  Some of the needs for student devices are time sensitive for student testing this spring.  For our staff, we need to replace laptops, desktops, projectors and ELMO document cameras.  There are many staff laptops and desktops that need to be replaced due to Windows 7 no longer being supported.

One of our biggest concerns is that the end of the Windows 7 lifecycle is set for January 14, 2020.  "End of life" means Microsoft will discontinue all support, including paid support; and all updates, including security updates. Between now and then, the operating system (OS) is in an in-between phase known as “extended support.” During this phase, Microsoft is offering paid support, though not the complimentary support that comes with the license; and will continue to provide security updates, but not design and feature updates. After Windows 7 "end of life," we can continue to use the OS, but at our own risk. New computer viruses and other malware are developed all the time and, without the security updates to fight them off, your data and your system are vulnerable. We have consulted with DataPath and they do not recommend that we opt for paid support, but instead update all of our Windows machines to Windows 10.

Business and Education Services have been working together to quantify the list of needs in order to look at funding options and the costs of these technology needs.  Our rough estimates indicate that the student needs are approximately $625,000 and the staff needs are approximately $900,000, totaling $1,525,000.

In our budget we have not identified the ability to cover all of these costs up front and have been looking into leasing options.  I have found three (3) types of leases available to us, as follows:

1) Lease To Own - we would own the devices at the end of the lease,

2) Fair Market Value - We would sell back the devices at the end of the lease and potentially start a new lease with new devices (more of a “true refresh” option), and

3) Tax Exempt Municipal Lease - Designed especially for municipalities like us, they are tax-exempt, we own the device up front and the lease has an “out clause” for non-appropriation of funds.  

We have also been researching what surrounding districts are doing and most of them are leasing because of the lack of funds, and also because it provides budget consistency and consistent refresh cycles of devices.  From the unaudited device inventory that has been provided over the last two months in Friday updates, it should be noted than many of our devices have 40% of our devices that are 5 years or older.  The Technology Department has identified those devices that can be updated to Windows 10 as well as those that are not upgradeable.

Attached is a summary and comparison with preliminary pricing for these various leasing options.  

Next steps will consist of finalizing the exact list of technology needs for students and staff, obtaining pricing, and updating leasing options to present to the Board of Trustees.






 
Attachments:
Tech Devices Leasing Options & Comparison
10.i. SUPERINTENDENT SEARCH
Time Certain:
8:55 PM
Speaker:
David Collins, Board President
Rationale:

SPEAKER: David Collins, Board President

Superintendent Debra M. Hendricks announced she will be retiring at the end of the 2019-2020 school year.  The Board of Trustees to discuss proposals to conduct a Superintendent Search for 2020-2021 school year.





 
Attachments:
COSCA GROUP PROPOSAL
LEADERSHIP ASSOCIATES PROPOSAL 2019
10.j. SAFETY AND FACILITIES UPDATE: BOARD QUESTIONS
Time Certain:
9:00 PM
Speaker:
Debra Hendricks, Superintendent and Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services
Rationale:

SPEAKERS: Debra Hendricks, Superintendent and Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services


 
11. ACTION ITEMS
11.a. APPROVAL OF CALIFORNIA SCHOOL EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION AND ITS CHAPTER 73 (CSEA 73) INITIAL ("SUNSHINE") PROPOSAL FOR 2019-2020 WITH SYLVAN UNION SCHOOL DISTRICT
Time Certain:
9:05 PM
Speaker:
Didi Peterson, Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Didi Peterson, Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources 

Initial proposals by both the District and a collective bargaining unit must be approved by the Board of Trustees before negotiations can commence.  California School Employees Association presents its Initial ("Sunshine") Proposal with Sylvan Union School District for Board approval to commence negotiations for the 2019-2020 agreement. 









 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends the Board pf Trustees approval of California School Employees Association and its Chapter 73 (CSEA 73) Initial ("Sunshine") Proposal with Sylvan Union School District for the 2019-2020 agreement and school year. 


Attachments:
CSEA SUNSHINE PROPOSAL 2019-2020
11.b. APPROVAL OF REVISED CLASSIFIED SALARY SCHEDULE
Time Certain:
9:10 PM
Speaker:
Didi Peterson, Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Didi Peterson, Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources 

In reviewing our current classified salary schedule, it was noted that our current wage in cells C1, D1 and E1 will need to be increased to $13.00/hour starting January 1, 2020. The District and California School Employees Association and its Chapter 73 (CSEA 73) have previously discussed and agreed upon the proposed changes to the salary schedule to ensure we meet the wage requirements.  As stated on the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement website for the State, “Although there are some exceptions, almost all employees in California must be paid the minimum wage as required by state law. Effective January 1, 2017, the minimum wage for all industries will be increased yearly.  From January 1, 2017, to January 1, 2022, the minimum wage will increase for employers employing 26 or more employees.”  In order to be compliant with the minimum wage rate for 2020, the pay rate for the affected cells will need to be adjusted. 

 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends approval of the revised Classified Salary Schedule.



Financial Impact:

The cost of the wage increase is dependent upon the number of new hires into the classification who will be placed in range C; currently seventeen (17) employees are impacted. Currently we do not have any employees in Range D and Range E1. The financial impact is not to exceed $4,000 for the remainder of the 2019-2020 school year. 









Attachments:
Current 2019-2020 Classified Salary Schedule
Draft 2019-2020 Classified Salary Schedule Proposal
11.c. APPROVAL OF KUREY & ASSOCIATES (USTACH MIDDLE SCHOOL MODERNIZATION)
Time Certain:
9:15 PM
Speaker:
Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services 

Division of Industrial Relations (DIR) requires all contractors and subcontractors working on public works projects to submit certified payroll records to the Labor Commissioner.  Prior to 2016, agencies were required to have a Labor Compliance Program approved by the DIR, or utilize a Labor Compliance Manager that was approved by the DIR.  Kurey & Associates was an approved vendor to supply the services, and the district has contracted with this vendor for labor compliance monitoring on all of our past large public works projects. 

After 2016 the DIR implemented an electronic certified payroll reporting system, and terminated the requirement for agencies to have a labor compliance program.  Although the requirement for a formal approved labor compliance program was eliminated, the regulations requiring agencies to ensure certified payroll for public works meet all regulatory requirements are still in effect.  We do not have staff trained nor staff time available to monitor labor compliance per public works regulations.  It is therefore necessary to continue labor compliance monitoring for our large construction projects.

The Ustach Middle School Modernization project requires a qualified labor compliance provider to assist in labor compliance needs. 

 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends the approval of Kurey & Associates as the Labor Compliance Consultant for the Ustach Middle School Modernization project.




Quick Summary / Abstract:

It is recommended the Board of Trustees approve Kurey & Associates as the Labor Compliance Consultant for the Ustach Middle School Modernization project.


Financial Impact:

Fiscal Impact: $27,700.00

Funding Source: Deferred Maintenance Fund 14





Attachments:
Kurey Quote
11.d. APPROVAL OF REVISED CAPITAL OUTLAY PLAN
Time Certain:
9:20 PM
Speaker:
Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services 

In March 2019, the Board of Trustees approved the 2019-2020 Capital Outlay Plan.  In this first quarter of the school year, the maintenance staff has worked diligently to make progress and complete some of these projects and will continue working on the projects throughout the remainder of the school year.  

As projects have been completed, actual costs have been updated on the capital outlay plan.  The attached capital outlay plan has been updated with these costs, as well as with other updates to address updated or unforeseen conditions at our sites or departments.  The Budget Variance columns indicate cost savings in green and overages in red.  Year to date we have cumulative savings of $92,438.  

Additional changes/updates to projects and/or estimated costs are in red font.  One of these most recent changes was the addition of the Ustach carpet, which was brought to the Board in a change order that was Board approved on October 15, 2019.  Other changes include the removal of projects and updates cost estimates, resulting in an overall revised total capital outlay plan total budget reduction of $47,780.  Any budget reductions/savings in the capital outlay plan will remain in the restricted and routine maintenance account to rollover and use the following fiscal year.  

See attached:

FY 2019-20 Capital Outlay Plan - REVISED 10-24-2019


 
Recommended Motion:

It is recommended the Board of Trustees approve the revised Capital Outlay Plan for 2019-2020.


Quick Summary / Abstract:

The Board of Trustees will consider approval of the revised Capital Outlay Plan for 2019-2020.



Financial Impact:

Budget Savings: $47,780

Routine Restricted Repairs & Maintenance Resource#8150


Attachments:
FY 2019-20 Capital Outlay Plan - REVISED 10-24-2019
11.e. APPROVAL OF CHRISTY WHITE ASSOCIATES TO CONDUCT THE SHERWOOD ELEMENTARY MODERNIZATION PROJECT PERFORMANCE AUDIT
Time Certain:
9:25 PM
Speaker:
Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services 

Pursuant to Education Code 41024, a District’s project is subject to an audit of the project by a local auditor that is in accordance with the Guide for Annual Audits of K-12 Local Education Agencies and State Compliance Reporting.  A project that receives any School Facility Program funds after April 1, 2017, is subject to said audit.

For the Sherwood Modernization project, we issued a Notice of Completion for this project in August 2013 and it was funded on April 12, 2018, five (5) years later.  Due to when the funds were received, we are subject to have an audit.  

The audit must be completed and submitted to the State Controller's Office by May 16, 2020.

 
Recommended Motion:
Staff recommends the acceptance of Christy White Associates to conduct the Sherwood Elementary Modernization Project Performance Audit. 



Quick Summary / Abstract:

The Board of Trustees to consider approval and acceptance of Christy White Associates to conduct the Sherwood Elementary Modernization Project Performance Audit.



Financial Impact:

$6,000.


Attachments:
Quote
11.f. ADOPT RESOLUTION – 2019/2020 #13: MAKING FINDINGS PERTAINING TO DEVELOPER FEES
Time Certain:
9:30 PM
Speaker:
Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services 

The District has been collecting school facilities developer fees under various authorities since 1986. Government Code Section 66006 (b) requires any public agency collecting developer fees to annually report on the status of these funds. 

Within one hundred eighty (180) days of the close of the fiscal year, districts must make available to the public information regarding the beginning balance, interest and other income, expenditures, refunds, and ending balance.  Districts must also identify each public improvement on which the fees were expended, the amount of expenditures on each improvement, and the total percentage of the improvement which was funded with fees.  Additionally, if districts have determined that sufficient funds have been collected to complete financing on an incomplete improvement, an approximate date by which the construction of the public improvement will commence must be identified.  Also, Districts must provide a description of each inter-fund transfer or loan made from the fund, including the public improvement on which the transferred or loaned fees will be expended and the date on which the loan will be repaid. 

The attached report provides revenue and expenditure detail for the 2018-19 fiscal year and the preceding four (4) years.

 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends the acceptance of the 2018-19 Fiscal Year Developer Fee Report and adoption of Resolution 2019/2020 #13: Making Findings Pertaining to Developer Fees.



Quick Summary / Abstract:

The Board of Trustees will consider acceptance of the 2018-2019 Developer Fee Report and adoption of Resolution 2019/2020 - #13: Making Findings Pertaining to Developer Fees. 




Financial Impact:

None

Attachments:
Five Year Activity Reports Ending June 30, 2019
Resolution- Dev Fees
11.g. ADOPT RESO 2019/2020 - #10: MAKING FINDINGS PERTAINING TO DESIGNATION OF SPECIFIC MATERIAL, PRODUCT, THING, OR SERVICE FOR USE ON MAINTENANCE PROJECTS
Time Certain:
9:35 PM
Speaker:
Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services 

Over the past several years, the District's maintenance department has made a conscious and deliberate effort to standardize a number of building systems, components, products and materials.  Staff has worked to find products that returned a solid value on the investment as well as provide simplicity of maintenance. 

The construction of new schools involves many building components and it is critical that components are compatible with systems and components at other schools within the District. 

In November 2004, the Board of Trustees adopted Resolution 2004/2005 - #07: Making Findings Pertaining to Designation of Specific Material, Product, Thing, or Service for Use on Maintenance Projects.  At that time, the Board of Trustees asked staff to review this resolution annually to ensure that products and model numbers remained current.  The Board of Trustees also requested the resolution be brought back on an annual basis for review and approval.  The attached resolution reflects the request and has been updated to include those items considered to be "District Standards." 

We do not have any changes from the items listed last year and we recommend staying with the current district standards.  

 
Recommended Motion:

It is recommended the Board Adopt Resolution 2019/2020 - #10: Making Findings Pertaining to Designation of Specific Material, Product, Thing, or Service for Use on Maintenance Projects


Quick Summary / Abstract:

The Board of Trustees will consider approval of Resolution 2019/2020 - #10: Making Findings Pertaining to Designation of Specific Material, Product, Thing, or Service for Use on Maintenance Projects.



Financial Impact:

None

Attachments:
Resolution 2019/2020 #10
11.h. RATIFICATION OF 2020 DEVELOPER FEE JUSTIFICATION STUDY
Time Certain:
9:40 PM
Speaker:
Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services 

The State Allocation Board (SAB) adjusts statutory developer fees every even-numbered year in the month of January. To increase the Level I fee, a district must prepare a new or updated developer fee justification study. A school district should also consider updating its study when circumstances change, such as when student enrollment decreases or classroom capacity increases.

Once a school district has prepared a new or updated developer fee justification study, it must publish a notice of public hearing in a newspaper of general circulation. 

Preparation of a developer fee justification study will begin the process for Sylvan USD to update our developer fee rates in January.  Capitol Public Finance Group has prepared previous developer fee studies for the district.  They will have our study “on the shelf” by December so that they can approve it shortly after the January 2020 School Allocation Board meeting.






 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends the approval of the 2020 Developer Fee Justification Study agreement with Capitol Public Finance Group. 


Quick Summary / Abstract:

It is recommended the Board of Trustees approve the 2020 Developer Fee Justification Study.


Financial Impact:

Fund 25 Developer Fees: $4,750


Attachments:
Agreement
11.i. APPROVAL OF BANKS GLASS FOR SAFETY AND ADA UPGRADES TO DISTRICT OFFICE ENTRYWAY
Time Certain:
9:45 PM
Speaker:
Sean Smith, Director of Maintenance & Operations
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Sean Smith, Director of Maintenance & Operations 

The current main entry doors at the District Office have been a maintenance, security, and safety concern. It is highly likely that they are the original doors that were installed when the building was constructed in 1975. 

Replacement parts for the panic hardware and lockset components become harder and harder to find every year.  ADA compliance for both the panic hardware and the threshold has come into question as well.  The doors cannot always be relied upon to latch properly and secure the building, particularly posing a safety concern during a lock down.

Quotes were solicited from a list of vendors that are authorized to install the District Standard “Oldcastle” brand of storefront doors.

Banks Glass: $10,680

Don’s Mobile Glass: $16,785

A-1 Glass: $19,286

 
Recommended Motion:

It is recommended that the Board of Trustees authorize the approval of Banks Glass for the safety and ADA upgrades to the District Office entryway, by purchase order in the amount of $10,680.








Financial Impact:

Routine Repair and Maintenance: $10,680 


Attachments:
DO Storefront Door Quotes
11.j. RATIFICATION OF CHANGE ORDER NO. 4 WITH UNITED PAVEMENT MAINTENANCE, INC FOR PAVING REPLACEMENT PROJECTS AT STOCKARD COFFEE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL.
Time Certain:
9:50 PM
Speaker:
Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Lizett Aguilar, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services 

There were existing utility boxes that were broken and had deteriorated when the pavement was removed. This occurred at Stockard Coffee Elementary School between the two (2) main buildings.  CB30 boxes are in ground utility boxes. (Christy Boxes).


This Change Order No. 4 is comprised of items listed on the attachment.

This Change Order will affect the contract as follows: 

Original Contract ................................................................. $802,934.00

Net Change by Previous Change Orders ........................... $113,931.49

Contract sum prior to this Change Order.................... ........ $916,865.49

The contract will be increased by this Change Order ......... $    1,698.53

The New Contract Sum including this Change Order ......... $918,564.02


 
Recommended Motion:

Staff is recommending the Board of Trustees ratify Change Order No. 4 with United Pavement Maintenance, Inc for Paving Replacement Projects at Stockard Coffee Elementary School.




Quick Summary / Abstract:

The Board of Trustees will consider Ratification of Change Order No. 4 with United Paving Management for Paving Replacement Projects at Stockard Coffee Elemenatary School.






Financial Impact:

$1,698.53

Attachments:
Change Order #4
11.k. APPROVE LIST OF OBSOLETE PROPERTY
Time Certain:
9:55 PM
Speaker:
Marti Reed, Director of Categorical Programs
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Marti Reed, Director of Categorical Programs 

Education Code 17546 allows districts to sell or dispose of obsolete property/instructional materials if the value of the item is less than $2,500.00 and the sale/disposal is approved by a unanimous vote of the Board of Trustees.  

Attached is the list by equipment district staff has determined to be in a condition unsuitable for continued use. Most of the items on this list are MacBooks and iPads that will be recycled through Device Cycles as presented to the Board of Trustees for approval at tonight’s board meeting.  All of these devices are no longer functioning to support the instructional environment. Items that are on this list have been evaluated as being no longer functional or are a threat to our network due to the operating system that cannot be updated. The laptops and PC towers represent some of the devices that are no longer functioning and cannot be upgraded to Windows 10. The Chromebooks included are some of the original devices purchased many years ago and are no longer operable or supported by Google. If parts were available on any of these devices to repair similar items, this was completed by the Sylvan Tech Team. The printers, projectors, and ELMOS listed are not able to be repaired at a cost effective rate due to their age. The servers are many years old and no longer functional on our network.




 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends the Board of Trustees declare the value of each obsolete item listed is less than $2,500.00; and authorize staff to dispose of the equipment in accordance with Education Code 17546.

Quick Summary / Abstract:

It is recommended the Board of Trustees declare the value of each obsolete item on the list is less than $2,500.00; and authorize staff to dispose of the equipment in accordance with Education Code 17546.

Financial Impact:

None

Attachments:
Obsolete Equipment List 10-29-2019 Board Meeting
11.l. APPROVE QUOTE FROM DEVICE CYCLE, LLC
Time Certain:
10:00 PM
Speaker:
Marti Reed, Director of Categorical Programs
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Marti Reed, Director of Categorical Programs 

Education Code 17546 allows districts to sell or dispose of obsolete property/instructional materials if the value of the item is less than $2,500.00 and the sale/disposal is approved by a unanimous vote of the Board of Trustees.  

As we move forward to ensure that our students are able to access on-line curriculum and resources effectively in January 2019 we replaced the original middle school 1:1 devices, iPad 2s, with new Chromebooks.  We explored ideas of deploying the iPad 2s to lower elementary grades, but the operating system can only be upgraded to iOS 9.3.5 which limits the use of applications that would be utilized in classrooms. The current iOS is 12.4.1.  In addition, for state testing the iOS version must be at least iOS 11.4. All of these devices have been wiped of all content. The iPad 2s were released in March 2011 and purchased as our first 1:1 devices for middle school students.

At the beginning of this school year we were forced to reconfigure every single middle school iPad Air because we were not able to successfully access the security certificate under the previous district user’s account.  The re-configuring brought to light some iPad Airs that will no longer function for instructional purposes. The Technology Department exhausted all measures to bring these up to the current operating system with no success.  These items have been added to the list of devices to sell. MacBook Pros that are also no longer functional on our network were also added to this list. All of these devices have been wiped of all content. After determining that these devices should not be redeployed out for use, I reached out to a company, Device Cycles, that provides an Apple Trade-In Program. 

Device Cycles' vision is to provide an eco-friendly and transparent solution for repurposing technology worldwide. Their mission is to build awareness by helping their customers capture the existing value that exist on technology. They are devoted to supporting both the ecosystem and humankind to make a positive change in the world.  As technology advances, older devices still hold value. Their trade-in programs prolong devices' lifespans by repurposing them to the next generation of owners. Upon receipt of our devices the evaluation process for each device includes a data erasure. Every device will generate the serial number and capacity. Their system then reinstalls the latest version of the iOS depending on the model ensuring all data has been erased.  After the data has been cleared, each device will have a certification of data destruction. Also during the evaluation period, Device Cycles will conduct high-quality images of our devices showing any cosmetic flaw details that provide full transparency and maximize recovered value. Their audit will grade the devices based on wear, tear or any defects the devices may have. Based on the evaluation of cosmetics and functionality of each individual device, they will conduct an audit report that includes the serial number, device type, condition and total value access.

On-Site pickup and custom packaging is included at no cost. Pick up date is within twenty-one (21) business days of approval offer.  Devices are initially quoted Grade A condition. If units do not meet Grade A specifications upon device evaluation, the correct grade and price listed on the quote will apply to the final reconciliation summary. We must receive the devices prior to the quote expiration date, devices received after the expiration date will result in a reduction of value based on current markets.




 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends the Board of Trustees approve the Device Cycles, LLC quote as presented revenue to the district in the amount of $28,768.




Quick Summary / Abstract:

It is recommended the Board of Trustees approve the Device Cycles, LLC quote as presented revenue to the district in the amount of $28,768.




Attachments:
Device Cycles Quote #Q0179
11.m. APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH THE LANGUAGE PEOPLE
Time Certain:
10:05 PM
Speaker:
Didi Peterson, Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Didi Peterson, Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources 

Currently, school sites and district departments utilize individuals to work as translators and interpreters to communicate and engage with non-English speakers in our community. At times we are not always able to find an interpreter for a specific language.  Both the Human Resources and Educational Services Departments recommend that the District begin to utilize the services of the Language People for phone-based and face to face interpreting, video interpreting, and conference interpreting for our families. This company provides translation and interpreting for over two-hundred (200) languages and dialects, including American Sign Language. The services would support requirements such as parent conferences and Individualized Education Plan (IEP) meetings. The Language People offers both scheduled and emergency or urgent requests for translating. 







 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends approval of the Agreement between Sylvan Union School District and The Language People for translation and interpreting services.

Quick Summary / Abstract:

The Language People Agreement rates includes differential pricing for both common and rare languages. In looking at the District's utilization of translators, we required translation services for languages that the Language People classify as "common". Languages that are most often requested included Spanish, Farsi, Arabic, Assyrian, and Russian. The Language People can provide translators for over two-hundred (200) languages and can make translators available in-person or by phone. They provide both scheduled and emergency/urgent appointments to meet the needs of the sites and departments.



Financial Impact:

In 2018-2019 the District's cost for translating and interpretation was $16,194.31. The translating services were utilized for parent conferences, parent and community events as well as Individual Education Plan meetings and assessments. The cost of these services in 2018-2019 was based on the hourly rate of $34.54. It is the District's intent to utilize Language People's phone interpretation as the primary tool with a rate of $1.50/minute with a minimum time charge of ten (10) minutes per call. The face to face interpretation rate is $75/hour for common languages and $85/hour for rare languages with a two (2) hour minimum for in-person translating services. The utilization will vary based on the needs of the sites and departments.

If the district determined that it wanted to solely use this outside service, based on the 2018-2019 utilization of translating services with a total of four hundred sixty nine (469) hours, the financial impact of this agreement would not exceed $35,000 for a complete school year.  If the district utilized these services only when a local translator could not be secured, the rates are listed above and in the attachment.








Attachments:
The Language People Agreement
11.n. APPROVAL TO APPOINT THE PARENT REPRESENTATIVE TO SELPA CAC (COMMUNITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE)
Time Certain:
10:10 PM
Speaker:
Dawn Mori, Director of Special Education
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Dawn Mori, Director of Special Education 

Our SELPA has a community advisory group that is part of the SELPA plan.  This advisory group includes parent representatives from each school district in our county.  Sylvan would like to recommend for the Board of Trustee’s approval, Melissa Stone, to represent the district as our parent representative on the committee.  Mrs. Stone has worked closely with the Special Education Department and the Director of Special Education to improve the education for all of our students.  She understands the needs of special education students, families, and the educational system as a whole.




 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends that the Board approve the appointment of Melissa Stone as our parent representative to the CAC committee for the 2019-2020 school year. 


11.o. RATIFICATION OF THE CONTRACT WITH EAST VALLEY CENTER FOR SERVICES
Time Certain:
10:15 PM
Speaker:
Dawn Mori, Director of Special Education
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Dawn Mori, Director of Special Education

A student moved into our school district that was currently placed through their Individualized Education Plan (IEP) at East Valley Education Center, Inc.  We are continuing that placement as outlined in the IEP.




 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends that the Board of Trustees approve the contract with East Valley Education Center, Inc. 



Financial Impact:

Special Education Fund: Not to Exceed: $35,000.




Attachments:
East Valley Contract
11.p. APPROVE CONTRACT WITH STANISLAUS COUNTY OFFICE OF EDUCATION - MVP MATH
Time Certain:
10:20 PM
Speaker:
Tierra Crothers, Director of Professional Learning and Induction
Rationale:

SPEAKER: Tierra Crothers, Director of Professional Learning and Induction

In light of switching our middle school accelerated math pathway we’re providing support to our teachers. Every attempt was made to provide introductory support over the summer yet unfortunately, the trainer cancelled the workshop. This provided us the opportunity to consult with Christina Rubalcava at Stanislaus County Office of Education (SCOE). In order to provide ongoing support, each teacher received coaching during a class period and follow up at their prep. In addition, SCOE will facilitate two (2) professional development opportunities:

  1. One half-day to support the implementation of Eureka Math curriculum for teachers in grade 6 

  2. One day to support the integration of productive mathematics discourse for 7th and 8th grade math teachers within Utah math lessons

All costs associated with the training and materials will be paid for out of general fund money that is set aside for Professional Learning.



 
Recommended Motion:

Staff recommends the Board of Trustees approve the contract with Stanislaus County Office of Education (SCOE) for onsite professional development services.


Quick Summary / Abstract:

It is recommended that the Board of Trustees approve the contract with Stanislaus County Office of Education for professional development services.



Financial Impact:

General Fund: $3,000

Attachments:
SCOE MATH PD 2019-2020
11.q. APPROVE EXPENDITURE OF CONSTRUCTION FUNDS
Time Certain:
10:25 PM
Speaker:
Lisa Sandoval, Director of Fiscal Services
Quick Summary / Abstract:

SPEAKER: Lisa Sandoval, Director of Fiscal Services 

It is recommended the Board of Trustees approve the expenditure of construction funds as listed.

Attachments:
FREEDOM PAINT PROJECT
PAVING PROJECT
SYLVAN WINDOW PROJECT
USTACH MODERNIZATION
USTACH PORTABLES
12. CONSENT AGENDA
Time Certain:
10:30 PM
12.a. APPROVE BOARD MEETING MINUTES
Speaker:
Debra M. Hendricks, Superintendent
Quick Summary / Abstract:

SPEAKER: Debra M. Hendricks, Superintendent

It is recommended that Board of Trustees approve the minutes of the October 8, 2019 Regular Board Meeting and October 15, 2019 Special Board Meeting.




Attachments:
MINUTES 10/15/19 SPECIAL BOARD MEETING
MINUTES 10/8/2019
12.b. RATIFICATION OF PERSONNEL ITEMSConfidential agenda item.
Quick Summary / Abstract:

SPEAKER: Didi Peterson, Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources 

It is recommended the Board of Trustees ratify the personnel actions as listed.

12.c. RATIFICATION OF CHECKS
Speaker:
Lisa Sandoval, Director of Fiscal Services
Quick Summary / Abstract:

SPEAKER: Lisa Sandoval, Director of Fiscal Services 

It is recommended the Board of Trustees ratify the list of checks as presented.

Attachments:
CHECKS
12.d. APPROVE DONATIONS
Speaker:
Debra M. Hendricks, Superintendent
Rationale:
The District has received donations as follows: 

1. The donation of $10.00 from YourCause Corporate Employee Giving Program to Freedom Elementary School for instructional materials, curriculum or interventions for students. 

2. The donation of $1,000.00 from Sherwood Parent Teacher Club to Sherwood Elementary School for the purchase of Unity Day t-shirts for all students.

3. The donation of $2,830.00 from Standiford Parent Teacher Association to Standiford Elementary School for class field trips.

 
Quick Summary / Abstract:
It is recommended the Board of Trustees approve the donations as listed.
13. SUPERINTENDENT'S REPORT
Speaker:
Debra M. Hendricks, Superintendent
14. BOARD REPORTS
15. FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
15.a. NEXT REGULAR BOARD MEETING - NOVEMBER 19, 2019
16. FINAL ADJOURNMENT
Time Certain:
10:35 PM

Published: October 25, 2019, 3:40 PM

The resubmit was successful.